This is my final product review from the package I received from Annabelle/Marcelle cosmetics. I received the Annabelle Smudgeliner in "OhMyGoth!" and have been using it everyday this past week for work. It's really quick and easy to use on those days when I don't feel like using liquid or gel liner. I ALWAYS smudge my pencil liner and this comes with a handy smudging tool on the end. I wish the tool was a bit smaller so I could be more precise because I find it bends too much and smudges the line out more than I personally like. The formula is great though. It's long lasting, stays put and glides on smooth and effortlessly. I tried using my MAC 219 are really like smudging the liner out with that.